Alright, I thought I'd sum up what has been written about the band in German newspapers etc. (basically it's spamming the forum with links but hey ho, I'm no moderator, I can do what I want 
:
http://www.toaster-os.de/rubriken/cd_tipps/the_feeling.html : Conclusion: "They've become more pop but betray themselves they have not completely. Nice album. Good to listen to. Pleasure of listening: 70%"
http://www.fr-online.de/in_und_ausland/kultur_und_medien/feuilleton/?em_cnt=1327887&sid=c29ea1350e7c070a16d5bbf6c7776973 : Excerpts: "There is probably no band on the planet that only exploits the success-promising elements of mainstream pop rock from the past four decades with such love of detail, and screws them together to songs that can only be called new with a lot of goodwill. [...] The self-acknowledged Supertramp fans that preferably perform in smart suits hit every note." (I love this newspaper for their reviews that are never sure what they think. Mind you, the headline is "Forever in the ski hut"!)
http://www.kulturnews.de/knde/index.php?id=7628&topic=platten&title=The+Feeling+-+Join+with+us : "... and a prog pop finale that redefines the borders of bad taste. Of course, songs like "I thought it was over" and "turn it up" do provide attraction. But you'd better succumb to those under a blanket". 3/6 stars
http://www.cnet.de/digital-lifestyle/musik/200992/the+feeling+join+with+us.htm : "It says "I think about growing colder without you / and my blood runs a little colder without you": Oh, heartache, oh, dolour. If only you could always be wrapped up in a three-minute pop song this beautifully. [...] Rating: excellent." (This is actually the most common review, I don't know where it's from originally but it must be from some sort of agency.)
http://www.soundbase-online.com/the-feeling-join-with-us : 7,5 / 12 points. (this seems to be a music mag for a change)
http://www.hr-online.de/website/radio/hr3/index.jsp?rubrik=4376&key=standard_document_34289148&tl=rs. It's Album of the Week on this radio station. They also did a review of the single: http://www.hr-online.de/website/radio/hr3/index.jsp?rubrik=4194&key=standard_document_34068512
http://www.bequeen.de/lifestyle/kultur/cd-tipp-%E2%80%93-the-feeling-%E2%80%93-join-with-us-62483 5 / 5 stars. (yay!!!)
http://www.zo-online.ch/article5322/Extra/CD-Tipps/Popstreifzug.htm: 4 / 5 stars (So what if it's Swiss? It's got a positive review so it's included!)
http://www.swr3.de/-/id=393494/l191mi/index.html : 3 / 6 indefinable things (it says elks but that can't be true)
And finally: http://www.now-on.at/kritiken.artikel.php?artikel=2440 : editor's rating: 5 / 7 stars, reader's rating 5 / 7 stars (again, this is German either but Austrian but anyway...).
Then I've got a vid which seems to be some kind of ad: http://video.universal-music.de/?vid=3532&g=uksounds
And two more short interviews: One with Dan (http://www.gay.ch/people/people/thefeeling.html) and one with Ciaran (http://www.students.de/magazin/det). Tell me to translate them and I will...
[Aimeeus Edit] I've fixed your links Sandi 
[Aimeeus Edit 2] I've also managed to delete the end of your post somehow.... oops! Sorry! 
[Sandi Edit] LOL. It's back there. Thank you!!! I'd've done it myself but I really needed some food.